**********Warning, Spoilers**********
I’ll start by saying that since I knew where it was going to end, as that scene faded I said “Well, that’s that.” Jenn and Lyz looked at me and said What? It’s over.
I left the theater with a feeling of Meh. It wasn’t awful. It wasn’t even bad. In fact, as a movie, it was quite good! But, as the movie shrew (my brother’s name for my problem) it wasn’t all that great. And it is all because of how they ended it, in my opinion. Sure, I had picked up on a ton of errors throughout the movie, but I do understand that the movie cannot be the book. Some things won’t work on-screen like they work in the book. Some things they screwed up in previous movies so that can’t really fix them in this movie without looking stupid.
But to me, the whole point of the book is Harry growing up and making the choice between boyhood fantasies and being a man and “protecting the world”. Hallows vs. Horcruxes. None of that was mentioned in the movie. They find out about the Hallows and drop the subject. They don’t even discuss the fact that Harry may very well have one of the Hallows in his possession.
Sure, they could fix this in the next movie, but it won’t be the same. In the book Harry chooses Horcruxes over Hallows by choosing to interview Griphook before Ollivander. By making this choice he makes it possible for Voldemort to go and get the Elder Wand. The movie ends with Voldemort taking the Elder Wand from Dumbledore’s hands. Gripbook and Ollivander were never interviewed.
12 hours after the movie ended I was still debating in my mind if I loved the movie, or just liked it. Again, I understand that the movie cannot copy the book. I do understand that some details must be removed. I do not understand why things must be added, or why some things must be changed. I am okay with the change in the way Hedwig dies. I understand that change. It is some of the little things that really bother me.
Then Danielle came to work. We looked at each other and I knew instantly that I did not love the movie. We managed to spend the next three hours discussing everything that was done wrong and how they could have changed it. Would it really have been too hard to put white peacocks in the Malfoy’s yard??????????? We went on and on and on and on about it. Coworkers stayed away from us. One made the mistake of asking us how we felt…and then ran away.
Danielle has now made it her goal to outline the things that were wrong. Yes, not all of them can be fixed, but MOST of them would have been easy additions/changes to make me feel like the movie was how I dreamed it could be.
For your enjoyment, Danielle’s notes on the minor things that could have been fixed to make the movie feel more like “home”:
1. Snape and Yaxley do not meet when entering Malfoy Manor.
2. No peacocks
3. Charity Burbage is not having above the table
4. Draco is not looking at it
5. Snape does not take the seat directly next to Voldemort (another thing that I think is crucial later on)
6. Malfoy’s do not show any displeasure with having Voldemort in their home.
7. In the book Bellatrix does not say she will kill HP for him. There is no discussion about their Tonks marrying a werewolf